Insurance agents in Lancaster, Pennsylvania

44 local agents in Lancaster rated by real Google reviews. Compare them below, then pick the ones you want to hear from — with iBundl, only the agents you choose reach out. No spam calls, and it's always free for you.

Start shopping — pick your local agents

Sean Kelleher - State Farm Insurance Agent

5.0 · 670 reviews
Lancaster, PA

HomeSale Insurance Services

5.0 · 464 reviews
Lancaster, PA

Forbes Insurance Agency - Geico & Erie Insurance

5.0 · 239 reviews
Lancaster, PA

Eagle One Insurance Agency

5.0 · 131 reviews
Lancaster, PA

DeverCare Insurance Group

5.0 · 66 reviews
Lancaster, PA

New Heritage Insurance Agency

5.0 · 29 reviews
Lancaster, PA

Insurance Services LLC

5.0 · 14 reviews
Lancaster, PA

North West Insurance Agency

5.0 · 10 reviews
Lancaster, PA

Success Insurance Lancaster

5.0 · 9 reviews
Lancaster, PA

Kling Bros. Insurance LLC

5.0 · 5 reviews
Lancaster, PA

ShipandInsure.com

5.0 · 4 reviews
Lancaster, PA

Levin Maxwell Insurance

5.0 · 3 reviews
Lancaster, PA

Ben Smith - State Farm Insurance Agent

5.0 · 3 reviews
Lancaster, PA

Horst Insurance

5.0 · 2 reviews
Lancaster, PA

Spoonhour Agency

5.0 · 1 reviews
Lancaster, PA

Alicia Alexander - State Farm Insurance Agent

4.9 · 207 reviews
Lancaster, PA

Susquehanna Insurance

4.9 · 200 reviews
Lancaster, PA

Red Rose Insurance

4.9 · 193 reviews
Lancaster, PA

Gebhard Insurance LLC

4.9 · 163 reviews
Lancaster, PA

Aubrey Montgomery - State Farm Insurance Agent

4.9 · 92 reviews
Lancaster, PA

HomeSale Settlement Services

4.9 · 82 reviews
Lancaster, PA

EHD Insurance

4.9 · 79 reviews
Lancaster, PA

Waller Insurance Agency

4.9 · 51 reviews
Lancaster, PA

Goosehead Insurance - Jake Brendle

4.9 · 33 reviews
Lancaster, PA

Walker Insurance Services

4.9 · 30 reviews
Lancaster, PA

Absolute Best Insurance

4.9 · 15 reviews
Lancaster, PA

Hinkle Insurance Agency - Erie Insurance

4.8 · 122 reviews
Lancaster, PA

Rick Milanak - State Farm Insurance Agent

4.8 · 46 reviews
Lancaster, PA

Bagnall Shaw Insurance

4.7 · 385 reviews
Lancaster, PA

Element | Insurance Agency - Lancaster

4.7 · 177 reviews
Lancaster, PA

Cornerstone Agency Services

4.7 · 44 reviews
Lancaster, PA

Robert Heinsinger: Allstate Insurance

4.7 · 29 reviews
Lancaster, PA

Acceptance Insurance

4.5 · 185 reviews
Lancaster, PA

Marco Salinas - State Farm Insurance Agent

4.5 · 39 reviews
Lancaster, PA

Community Insurance

4.5 · 27 reviews
Lancaster, PA

Highmark Direct Health Insurance Store

4.5 · 8 reviews
Lancaster, PA

BCF Group Inc

4.4 · 33 reviews
Lancaster, PA

Ruhl Insurance

4.4 · 14 reviews
Lancaster, PA

Lee Kennedy - State Farm Insurance Agent

4.3 · 44 reviews
Lancaster, PA

Nationwide Insurance: Barbara J Lapp Lutcf

4.2 · 6 reviews
Lancaster, PA

Hermes Almaguer: Allstate Insurance

4.0 · 59 reviews
Lancaster, PA

David E Gebhard and Associates

4.0 · 4 reviews
Lancaster, PA

Murray

3.1 · 10 reviews
Lancaster, PA

Progressive Insurance - Claims Office

2.9 · 39 reviews
Lancaster, PA

How iBundl works in Lancaster

You pick the agents — not the other way around

Shopping insurance normally means one quote form and then days of spam calls. iBundl flips it: you browse Lancaster agents by rating, choose the ones you like, and only those agents can reach you.

Local agents, home & auto

The agents above are real, licensed insurance professionals serving Lancaster, Pennsylvania — the neighbors who can quote your home and auto and actually pick up the phone.

Always free for consumers

iBundl is free for shoppers. You control who contacts you, and you can start from your couch in a couple of minutes.

Find your Lancaster insurance agent

Ratings and review counts shown are from public Google data. iBundl is a consumer-first local insurance marketplace — not a lead vendor.